Inclusion, Fairness, Transparency in Peer Review
A platform for scientists and researchers to exchange insights on peer-reviewed journals, pose inquiries, and engage in constructive discussions.
Community Highlights
Check out what’s trending! Engage with the conversations that are sparking the most interest.
Explore DiscussionsResources
A dynamic space for debate, exchange of ideas, and open communication, fostering a deeper understanding of the evolving landscape of academic publishing and science.
Our Purpose
- Breaking Barriers
- Building Bridges
- Redefining Scientific Discourse
The peer review process serves as the foundation of scientific inquiry. Our goal is to make it fair, transparent, and inclusive.
Your voice matters
Share
your experiences anonymously or openly
Inquire
about any peer-reviewed journal
Engage
in constructive feedback with your peers
Amplify your voice and impact the research community. Contribute to holding journals accountable and advancing transparency in academia.
Support our work
We are committed to ensure a safe, impartial environment free from ties to publishing companies. Our neutrality allows users to express their perspectives freely. Operated by a small team, we rely on user support to cover operational costs. You can contribute through one-time sponsorships or subscriptions, keeping the platform accessible for all scientists. Additionally, we supplement revenue with Google Ads.
Most Voted Comments
Computers and Industrial Engineering
I have multiple publications here over the years and I have very mixed opinions. For one of my papers, everything…
European Journal of Operational Research
EJOR is a major player in the world of operations research, with a wide range of research streams that sometimes…
Computers and Operations Research
I have had multiple experiences with CAOR; some of them ended negatively and others ended with a published article. Although…
Education and Information Technologies
I had my first publishing experience with this journal a few years ago, and while it was a bit disappointing,…
Frontiers in Sociology
I have always been curious about Frontiers journals, as they present themselves as part of a new generation of journals…
Most Active Threads
I submitted to this journal only once, and it turned out to be a very reliable experience. Although we received…
I had my first publishing experience with this journal a few years ago, and while it was a bit disappointing,…
I submitted my work to Language, Culture and Curriculum in the first half of 2024. I chose this journal because…
Most Commented Journals
Applied Energy
Education and Information Technologies
Frontiers in Sociology
Language, Culture and Curriculum
Journal of Child and Family…
Most Recent Comments
My experience with Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft (ZfE) was very positive. The review process was quite long, similar to many other…
It’s honestly crazy how some reviewers act like they’re all powerful. Glad the editorial process wasn’t a nightmare though. That…
Sounds like a pretty balanced experience overall. Harsh reviews can be tough, but it’s good that you were able to…
The journal publish so many papers, it makes you wonder how they actually manage to review all of them properly.…
My experience with Applied Energy was good. Although my first submission was rejected, they suggested that I incorporate their comments…